12 Accurate… The five-episode series will air over the course of three consecutive nights, beginning on Sunday, April 24. A Commemoration of the Decade of Revolution 1912-1923. And for an armed and bloody insurrection, this Rising is remarkably free of tension. Created by Colin Teevan. The series was produced to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the Easter Rising. In the series Claire Randall, a nurse from the Second Wold War, travels back in time to Scotland in 1743 just prior to the Jacobite risings. Is your workplace ready for a hybrid future? People “suffer for days before dying," he told the outlet, and this may be true, but it doesn't exactly make a strong argument that Rebellion is an accurate representation of the history it aims to depict. Can anyone tell me how historically accurate netflix's Original, Roman Empire: Reign of Blood, is? It’s not the best out there but it is engaging enough to watch to see how it ends. It hasn’t worked out that way. Oakland A's general manager Billy Beane's successful attempt to assemble a baseball team on a lean budget by employing computer-generated analysis to acquire new players. One of the most unsatisfactory aspects of Rebellion is the wordy pronouncements used to tell the story, that puts stilted dialogue in nearly all of the characters’ mouths at some point. 3. Please subscribe to sign in to comment. To comment you must now be an Irish Times subscriber. The rebellion draws first blood on the day after Easter, when militants storm government buildings in the heart of Dublin. The RTÉ drama’s leading action man Jimmy (Brian Gleeson) is saved from the firing squad along with Éamon de Valera. The show is very loosely based on the historical events leading up to and surrounding the Battle of Teutoburg Forest in 9 CE, in which an alliance of several Germanic tribes won a crushing victory against the … In episode two, which was by far the weakest, middle-class medical student Elizabeth (Charlie Murphy) jilts her soldier fiance and joins the rebels – and Jim, her crush. WB Yeats to be honoured with London sculpture, Nine-year-old earns €24m as the highest-paid YouTuber of 2020, Claire Byrne isn’t just a rigorous interviewer. Many history buffs are undoubtedly excited for the premiere of Sundance's miniseries Rebellion . The story is told from the perspectives of a group of fictional characters who live through the political events of the 1916 Easter Rising. Starring: Brian Gleeson, Simone Kirby, Natasha O'Keeffe. We are told by several characters that the mood in Dublin is changing – support for the rebels is rising. Dublin’s violent Easter Rising of 1916 ignites a long and bloody conflict between British military forces and Irish revolutionary fighters. But for everything The King excels at, its lack of historical accuracy is sure to drive any historian a little crazy. If you think that this makes it a “white supremacist propoganda” movie, than the way you watch entertainment is tainted to say the least. The second series begins at around 1671, a few years after Season 1 ended. Shaw and his men accompanied Colonel James Montgomery’s force and … They were speechless’: How a €3m painting was discovered, Ideas for a new Ireland: ‘I pray for an Ireland free of sly bucks on the make’, You may be outside more this summer, so don’t forget to protect your skin, 10 amazing destinations on the Wild Atlantic Way, Saving the planet one bar of chocolate at a time. Your screen name should follow the standards set out in our. The events in the immediate wake of 1916 give Rebellion writer Colin Teevan a dramatic ending to the five-part RTÉ series, which ended last night. Margot Robbie and Saoirse Ronan star as two rival queens, although the drama has drawn criticism for … Because showrunners chose to focus on the development of fictional characters, it seems that detailed historical accuracy was not a top priority. The story begins with Louis having a vision to build a great and grand palace at Versailles. Netflix Marco Polo Series 'Riddled With Historical Errors' According to Mongolian historians, much of the series' plot plays fast and loose with the facts. There is no evidence that the Emperor, nor even the … Marcus Aurelius wanted to restore the Republic. The story is told through the perspective of a group of fictional characters who live through the political events. Commenting on The Irish Times has changed. Surrender ... Netflix … Made 20 years ago it would have been a grand period drama with good production values and strong acting. A report in Radio Times, reveals that much Netflix’s The Last Kingdom, Barbarians is partly based on real history and partly a work of fiction. 2021 Bustle Digital Group. reviews went downhill by the second episode, the historical facts aren't necessarily as black-and-white as we may assume, she explained how she approached her role. We’ve been told, too, that Dublin is destroyed but there’s little sense of that either. The show they were making is a shocker too, Do the Irish really swear more than other nations? Now, though, as we learn more about the events of Easter 1916 – largely through the centenary coverage in print and on television – we know its history is filled with real drama, extraordinary events and fascinating characters (some of them women). Several female characters in the final episode make rallying feminist speeches – Elizabeth at her trial, the tenement mammy, even lawyer George’s girlfriend Ingrid – one of the many extraneous, plot thinning two-dimensional characters, like Liz’s cad of a brother, Harry. Rebellion’s timing is – ironically – unfortunate. One of the most accurate scenes in the movie is the burning of Darien, Georgia, on June 11, 1863. As British forces clamp down on Dublin, Frances and Elizabeth continue to support the insurgents, and May faces a trying domestic situation. Still, Murphy raises an important point — although many scenes we see will be purely fictional, they will reflect what it was like to live through an incredibly tumultuous and frightening era. Rebellion is a 2016 historical drama television serial written and created by Colin Teevan for RTÉ. Votes: 378,095 | … With Michael Ford-FitzGerald, Jaelynne Wallace Ruane, Jordanne Jones, Brian Gleeson. The series follows Emily through her young adult years and explores the poet's struggles with love, family, gender norms and other social issues. Director: Bennett Miller | Stars: Brad Pitt, Robin Wright, Jonah Hill, Philip Seymour Hoffman. The process of selecting a new pope is kept a secret from the public—at least, it’s supposed to be. It wasn’t until 1947 that things seemed to be status quo. It is a historical fiction, which means the premise is based on true stories while the characters are fictionalized. But what of “the three little maids” introduced in the first episode? So this was definitely an instance where it benefitted the story more than it was actually historically accurate. The series is a dramatisation of the events surrounding the 1916 Easter Rising. The old senators still haven't forgotten the loss of Armenia to Tiridates and with the Jewish revolt flaring up, it became more and more questionable whether Nero could really handle running an empire. Deranged disciple of Patrick Pearse, Frances (Ruth Bradley), has been blooded by the Rising – she makes a speech about not living by men’s rules any more, dresses as a man, kisses May on the lips and kills the only detective in the Dublin metropolitan police. Rebellion by noble… This kidnapping was creativity, which likely never occurred in Louis' reign. If you didn’t know them you would have thought they’d taken ecstasy’, Frequently asked questions about your digital subscription, Specially selected and available only to our subscribers, Exclusive offers, discounts and invitations, Explore the features of your subscription, Carefully curated selections of Irish Times writing, Sign up to get the stories you want delivered to your inbox, An exact digital replica of the printed paper, Eoin Mac Neill was open to armed struggle, 1916 gathering told, Not Army’s role to explain 1916 in schools, says John Bruton, 1916 Proclamation needs more critical scrutiny, says expert, Easter Rising relatives gather at launch of oral history collection, Sinn Féin to hold ardfheis on eve of 1916 Rising centenary, The Rising of Easter 1916 is ‘live’ and politically radioactive, Medals awarded to Rising Volunteers to be auctioned in US, Volunteer medals go on sale in New York auction, ‘The Irish Times’ publishes comments from international press on first World War, Flanagan says 1916 events in US must be ‘inclusive’, Chloe Agnew: My great-grandfather was in the GPO, Church events in January to highlight 1916 centenaries. But there’s little sense of it. The Independent reported that, although the first episode received positive feedback, reviews went downhill by the second episode. Rebellion is a miniseries created by Collin Teevan and directed by Catherine Morshead. Catnip for the Historically Minded. If we can’t agree on a name, does Northern Ireland even exist? But it’s too late, Rebellion lost its feminist badge in episode four: at a key moment, the rebels surrender at Moore Street, it replaced nurse Elizabeth O’Farrell, who actually carried the white flag, with a man. The popular TV show Outlander , now in its fifth season, is based on a series of historical novels written by Diana Gabaldon. Netflix Outlaw King . According to the The Journal.ie, he claimed that the historical facts aren't necessarily as black-and-white as we may assume: "This is definitely a period of history in Ireland that people have different emotions about, or strongly disagree over." Despite some historical inaccuracies and a dependence on character drama to keep things moving forward, Rebellion is worth checking out if you like historical dramas. Civil Servant May (Sarah Green) is given a hackneyed period-drama plot – lowly girl pregnant by her toff boss – and she spends much of the series in unlikely scenes in a big house in suburbia with his wife Vanessa. How historically accurate is the new Mary Queen of Scots film? The premiere date is symbolic — it's the 100th anniversary of when Ireland's Easter Rising began. The new Netflix animated series Yasuke is a fanciful mess. Please enter your email address so we can send you a link to reset your password. It also teases that these characters will "play vital and conflicting roles in the narrative of Ireland’s independence." How accurately Henry V and Agincourt are portrayed in the Netflix drama and Shakespeare plays The film is an adaptation of Shakespeare’s group of … The article pointed out factual inaccuracies in specific scenes and went on to state that history experts had a number of complaints, from the costumes to the depictions of the historical figures: Shortly after these criticisms emerged, the show's director Aku Louhimies, responded to them and defended the depiction of the Rising. She remains in her white wedding dress and blue coat throughout like a dress-up Virgin Mary. The ensemble cast includes Charlie Murphy, Ruth Bradley, Sarah Greene, Brian Gleeson, Niamh Cusack, Michelle Fairley and Ian McElhinney. Louhimies also noted that he strived to not romanticize the events — for example, the show depicts people lying in the streets suffering for prolonged periods after being shot. Versailles - a guide to its historical accuracy Historian and presenter of Inside Versailles , Greg Jenner, separates the fact from the fiction as series one of Versailles comes to its end. In a broad sense, like “Ceaser crossed the Rubicon” and “Augustus sent an assassin to kill Cicero, who legend claims ignored the assassin while he was attacked” are accurate, but all the drama, interpersonal relations, and sex scandals are either invented or taken from gossip at the time. Rebellion is a five part serial drama about the birth of modern Ireland. 4. In “El Cid,” you sense the first inklings of a democratic rebellion against unaccountable autocracy. Barbarians Historical Accuracy Is Barbarians based on a true story? Originally Answered: How historically accurate is HBO's Rome and Netflix's Roman Empire? By this point, the Dauphin (the eldest son and heir of Louis XIV) has been recovered and the plot against him by Protestants and the Dutch has been thwarted. There have a been a lot of Netflix originals related to ancient history recently. You should receive instructions for resetting your password. Although Hitler and his Nazi party enforced great control over the German population during World War 2, there were still isolated groups who could not be swayed by the Nazis fearful influence. We reserve the right to remove any content at any time from this Community, including without limitation if it violates the, For the best site experience please enable JavaScript in your browser settings, How we celebrate 1916 will shape future - Methodist leader, Rite&Reason: The ‘altruistic evil’ of 1916 Rising, ‘The owners’ faces turned pale. This dramatic device of creating fictitious ones now looks like a wasted opportunity. Turns out, the style is historically accurate, and we all know how far Timmy’ll go to uphold the integrity of a role (peaches included). With its contemporary soundtrack and dialogue, Apple TV+'s Dickinson makes it clear from the outset that this isn't going to be a completely accurate depiction of Emily Dickinson's life in the nineteenth century. Enjoy countryside living in a home that’s perfect for family and entertaining, Poetry round-up: Shetland landscapes to river gods, Lean Fall Stand: Eloquent mapping of geographer’s disorientation, Reading Covid-19 round-up: Focusing on the failures of science and government, ‘It was a ticking timebomb’: Inside the rise and fall of The Jeremy Kyle Show, The Irish Times guide to Ireland’s reopening museums, galleries and heritage sites, Remember the Dominic West-Lily James kiss shock? Uprising is an American 2001 war drama television miniseries about the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising during the Holocaust.The film was directed by Jon Avnet and written by Avnet and Paul Brickman.This miniseries was first aired on the NBC television network over two consecutive nights in November 2001. While many social media users expressed frustration with the show's inaccuracies, others defended it for showing an important aspect of the Rising that may not be in the history books: And, even Charlie Murphy, who stars as Elizabeth Butler, pointed out that the series isn't meant to be a history lesson. But it actually took years for things to go back to normal for everyone involved in the war. If you enjoyed the absolutely brilliant Peaky Blinders, this spy thriller will surely have you engaged. Made 20 years ago it would have been a grand period drama with good production values and strong acting. It’s May 12th and the trials of the rebels continue; the execution of an injured James Connolly is unseen – a wise decision by director Aku Louhimies – but still shocking . Rebellion is historical fiction and it sounds like we should take the show's historical aspects with a grain of salt. April 24 won't be the first time critics and viewers watch Rebellion — in January, the miniseries aired in Ireland and it faced criticism for a number of historical inaccuracies. How historically accurate is Outlander? A direct descendant of Newt Knight’s grandfather, he was heavily involved in researching the film and ensuring its historical accuracy. Netflix’s new historical drama La Révolution, an eight-hour series directed by Aurélien Molas, doesn’t so much bend history as it snaps it across its knee, fashioning its pieces into a bonfire around which to tell nationalist feel-good fairy tales and ghost stories.La Révolution is not about the French Revolution but rather, the idea of the French Revolution. It never claimed to be historically accurate, as it was very obvious that 99% of the movie was fiction. The showrunners Jan Martin Scharf and Arne Nolting have reportedly aimed for achieving a high level of authenticity in what audiences see on screen. Braveheart has been called one of the least accurate historical movies ever made, a harsh critique when you consider films like 10,000 BC, Pocahontas , JFK , and Pearl Harbor . Who gives a f***, Louise Nealon: ‘There is an overwhelming silence and shame in Irish culture’. The characters are fictional, but how accurate is Sundance's Rebellion? The account details entered are not currently associated with an Irish Times subscription. This name will appear beside any comments you post. 2016 | TV-MA | 1 Season | Political TV Shows. In an interview with The Irish Mirror, she explained how she approached her role: Rebellion is historical fiction and it sounds like we should take the show's historical aspects with a grain of salt. As we learn more about the events of Easter 1916 we know its history is filled with real drama, extraordinary events and fascinating characters. According to Sundance's official website, the series will open with the outbreak of World War I and will depict the "tumultuous events that follow" as seen through the eyes of three young women and their friends, families, and lovers. When you have reset your password, you can, Please choose a screen name. It seemed then they might be interesting, rebellious types; that Rebellion would help to rebalance the airbrushing of women out of the Rising story. Set in 16th century Japan, it features mechs, magic, evil Jesuits, zombie samurai, and Lovecraftian evils from outside space-time. Under Siege 52m. 87 Metascore. Jimmy, who has spent much of the series haring through Dublin with Frances (Ruth Bradley), pals up with Michael Collins and has a go at de Valera. Historian Fiona Watson has her say on Netflix's Robert the Bruce epic. All rights reserved. The film boasts enormous cinematic landscapes and fight sequences as well as top-notch acting from the likes of Chalamet, Joel Edgerton, and Robert Pattinson. How historically accurate is the film "Swing Kids" in its portrayal of the actual "Swing Kids" and other elements of Nazi youth?. Rebellion’s timing is – ironically – unfortunate. The palace is depicted as a symbol for France and in the first season Louis attempts to instill in his nobility that the palace is to represent all of France and his role in building it is essentially to unify the country (Figure 1). There was continued unrest, however, stemming from earlier revolts against the King and French nobility in general, during the Although the palace is known today for its grand opulence such as the Hall of Mirrors and other structures, the intent was to make this building project help centralize the state itself. One such show is the German historical drama series Barbarians, which was first released on Netflix on 23 October 2020.